PBJ From Scratch

Everything you could want in a peanut butter and jelly. Homemade creamy peanut butter, jam, and whipped salted butter, layered onto fresh baked, soft sandwich bread.
Save this recipe!
Get this recipe sent to your inbox.

Ingredients 

  • SANDWICH BREAD:
  • 130 g or 1/2c warm water, 86F/30C
  • 5 g or 2tsp instant yeast
  • 1 egg
  • 45 g or 3 1/4Tbsp melted butter, not hot
  • 45 g or 3 2/3Tbsp granulated sugar
  • 100 g roasted and riced russet potatoes, about 1/2-2/3 of 1 potato, peel, wrap in foil and roast at 400F/205C for 1 hour
  • 430 g or 3 1/2c AP flour
  • 10 g or 1 3/4tsp kosher salt
  • RASPBERRY JAM, makes about 2 pints:
  • 500 g or 4c fresh raspberries
  • 75 g or 1/3c lemon juice
  • 75 g or 1/3c white distilled vinegar
  • 700 g or 3.5c granulated sugar
  • 60 g or 1/3c + 2Tbsp regular fruit pectin
  • PEANUT BUTTER:
  • 500 g or 3.5c spanish or runner peanuts, I’m using spanish
  • WHIPPED SALTED BUTTER:
  • 450 g/1lb room temp butter
  • 3-4 g/Pinch kosher salt

Instructions 

  • SANDWICH BREAD:
  • Using dough hook attachment, mix on medium for 4 mins. Increase speed to high and mix for a additional 7-8min. Dough should be clearing the bowl and pass the tug test when done.
  • Round dough into a taught ball (see video @__1:45__). Cover bowl & ferment at room temp for 2 hours.
  • Prepare a 1.5lb loaf pan with oil or pan spray.
  • Flip dough onto lightly floured surface and press to degas. Shape as shown in video @__6:52__ and place into pan, seam side down. Mist with water, cover with towel, & proof at room temp for 60-90min.
  • Mist loaf well with water then score top.
  • Load into preheated 400F/205C oven, spritz oven well with 12-15 spritzes of water, & bake for 30min.
  • RASPBERRY JAM:
  • Add all ingredients except pectin to a heavy bottomed pot over high heat. When mix reaches a simmer, stir to combine.
  • Cook until tender for about 10min. When mixture begins to foam, reduce heat to med/med-high , stirring occasionally.
  • Strain seeds out of ⅓-½ of the mixture, making sure to force all juice and pulp back into the mix. Discard strained seeds.
  • Return pot to high heat and bring to a boil then whisk in fruit pectin and continue boiling and reducing until temp reaches 220F/105C.
  • Ladle into jars with lids and cool to room temp then refrigerate for 12 hours to set.
  • PEANUT BUTTER:
  • Spread peanuts onto sheet tray and roast at 300F/150C for 40-50min. Add to food processor and process for 10-12mins or until smooth and creamy.
  • WHIPPED SALTED BUTTER:
  • Mix with whisk attachment on high for 3-5min until fluffy and lightened in color.
  • TO BUILD THE PBJ:
  • Cut thick slices of bread. Spread 2 large spoons of peanut butter on 1 slice. Top with a pinch of flaky salt. On the other slice of bread, spread 2 spoons of butter. Squeeze jam on top of peanut butter (rather than spreading) to maintain layers of each ingredient.
iconLike this? Leave a comment below!

Share this post:

Brian lagerstrom tossing pizza dough in kitchen

About Brian

As a former professional chef, I’m obsessed with creating well-designed recipes that not only taste good, but that are practical and fun for home cooks to re-create. You can browse my recipes here or head to my YouTube channel to watch all of my recipe videos.

You May Also Like

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating